The EA Sports FC 24 cover has been revealed and it’s pretty much just getting memed to death.

The picture will be on the front of the FC 24 Ultimate Edition, and it packs in a bunch of popular soccer stars from different generations in a group setting. But unfortunately, the longer you look at the picture the more you’ll become drawn to the rather unsettling appearance of the sports stars’ faces.

A lot of reactions are comparing the facial renderings to old PS1 or PS2 games, but I wonder if it could be the exact opposite. Are the faces rendered so faithfully to the actual people, while still not being quite photorealistic, that they take on a certain uncanny valley effect, almost like those weirdly realistic wax figures of celebrities? You be the judge:

(Image credit: EA)

Yeah, the more I ponder the question, the more I’m convinced these faces are actually just a bit shoddy looking, especially for a cover shot! While there are plenty of FIFA fans who could apparently care less about the visual fidelity of the soccer stars, the reaction from the community largely consists of memes, some taking aim directly at the game’s version of certain players, and others just poking fun at the scene in general.

FC 24 is of course EA Sports’ replacement for FIFA, and once you’ve had enough of the memes, you can check out the first trailer here, showing the same group of players looking much more normal both in the locker room and on the field. The game launches on September 29.

The FIFA name will live on in the “best egame for any boy or girl,” according the organization’s boss.